Whitchurch Whereigo - should it stay or should it go?

We've had a Whereigo cache live for quite a while now. It's a nice walk around the North Shropshire town of Whitchurch and takes a light-hearted look at the town's historic clock-making industry (it's more interesting than it sounds - honest!).

We have a self-imposed rule of not hiding micros, so in the case of this cache, we had our work cut out for us as there are not a lot of places that are:

• Nice locations
• Close to the town center
• Able to take a small or better still, a regular size cache

In fact, we only found the one place that fits all the criteria and it's been getting some nice comments.

The original Regular sized cache was muggled after a few months so we replaced it by a Small sized cache in the same place, but pushed further in so it was less obvious to muggles. This has also been muggled recently, so it's obviously time to move the hide a bit.

Our dilemma now is if we do move it, we'll almost certainly have to make the cache a micro which we really do not want to do.

On the other hand, most if not all of the likely suspects have already done the cache so we're wondering if it's worth the effort to replace the cache. Maybe we should just archive it and chalk it up to experience?